One of my readers PMed me last week, asking me to blog about what I thought about Amy Chua's book and WSJ article. Although I believe this topic has been beaten to a bloody pulp, it is a pretty important topic to talk about because I will be a parent one day.
Long time readers would know that I often discuss about the way my parents raised me. It was always different than from my friends and classmates, even amongst the Chinese families. I had relatively the same rules Amy Chua had for her daughters, even going as far as discouraging me from drawing and other arts, forcing me to focus only on academics.
During one summer before second or third grade year, I had to stay in and memorize the multiplication table. I had to recite it fast without messing up, from multiples of 2 through 9. My heart wasn't into it because kids were playing outside, but I had no choice. In the third grade, I received a "gift" from them, a complete set of encyclopedias. For three hours a day, for three years, I had to read it. After homework and such, reading it took up most of my time. Although I know a lot of things now, even in hindsight, I'm not sure if it was a good thing since I felt that I "lost" my childhood.
Throughout most of my academic career, many of the top kids of every class were Asian. Of the non-Asians, they were Jews. While I envied the freedom many of the other kids had, I was prideful of doing well. But even then, I felt that my parents were pushing me too hard, one time even criticizing me for coming home with a 107 on a midterm, and not getting the full 10 extra credit points.
Being pulled between East and West cultures, I rebelled against them, going as far as dropping out of school. I needed fun in my life, but that didn't fit into their plans.
It took many years for me to really get over what happened between us. It actually wasn't until a year after I graduated from college did I realize that my grudge was stupid. I may not agree with what they did, but what they did was done with good intentions.
Reading Amy Chua's article, I really felt a strong agreement with her methods. While I wouldn't go as far as forcing them to only play certain instruments or disallowing them to star in plays, I would be really strict with academics. I do believe that most kids can learn any material. Some just require more practice than others.
I truly believe that the modern child grows up with a sense of entitlement. They are babied by their parents. My parents beat me till I was 16. The modern child would have probably called the cops on their parents as soon as they knew how. I won't beat my kids, but there are about 1000 ways to punish them. I would be the strict parent and won't be nice. I won't try to be their friends until they I feel that they are old enough to be.
I have quite a few friends who are teachers and they often tell me about how parents complain to them about giving too much homework or making the work too hard. It bothers me that these parents do not realize that they are failing their children. Children don't know better. If we want to give them more than what we had growing up, it starts with teaching them what hardwork is all about.
Thinking back, my parents never told me that I needed to be a doctor or lawyer or accountant. They just wanted me to do well because only then, are more opportunities open to us. I'm surprised there are so many critics. Asians have the highest rate of being professionals in this country. Is it really a surprise that all it takes is being diligent and doing well in school?
While Amy Chua doesn't outright say her way (the Eastern way) is the better way, I will say that it is. Doing well academically, does in fact open more doors. And does it really affect the development of social skills? I can't say I'm socially inept.
What are your thoughts on the matter?
** ** ** **
WWJD?
Recent Comments